And he was involved in at least one feast, the feast of dedication john 10. The book outlines twentynine principles organized in the following areas. The regulative principle of worship the reformed understanding of the practice of biblical worship is usually summarized by the regulative principle of worship rpw. The regulative principle of worship and christmas by brian schwertley free online book. Sola scriptura and the regulative principle of worship. Normative vs regulative principle the puritan board. Either we approach the living god according to his revealed word i. That we in no wise make any image of god, nor worship him in any other way than he has commanded us in his word. Stonecampbell hermeneutics iv regulative principle. Sadly, most protestant churches and even churches reformed in their soteriology are often closer to rome than the reformation in their public worship, practicing such roman catholic innovations in public worship as signing manmade hymns rather than the using the hymn book god has provided in scripture, and singing psalms, using musical.
Free reformation and puritan books, mp3s, debates and articles on puritan and reformation worship scroll down for free resources reformed worship, the regulative principle, etc. Mar 10, 2004 we have seen that the puritan regulative principle of worship was an exaggeration of, and departure from, the worship practice of john calvin, whom the puritans regarded as a leading father in the faith. These are principles that are held and practiced particularly by reformed and presbyterian churches, although some of them we. Frame, john some questions about the regulative principle. Would the use of a phrase span the spectrum between the regulative and normative principles of worship in a presbytery document signal that rpw is no longer even expected in the pca. But it is worthy of notice that the regulative principle also agrees with many other vital biblical principles of the reformed faith. Hart and muether discuss two key reformed principles of worship, the regulative and the dialogical. The reformed understanding of this principle states that only those elements that are commanded in scripture or which can be deduced by good and necessary consequen. Some of the regulative principle groups reject the use of musical instruments in worship on this ground 1.
On the surface, it is difficult to see why anyone who values the authority of scripture would find such a principle objectionable. Which is correct, the regulative principle or the normative principle of worship. My last post described how churches of christ have utilized the baconian method. Known to his friends as scoti from a nickname he earned at centre college as an undergraduate, old had suffered declining health in recent years. Aug 12, 2003 two areas with respect to reformed worship present themselves as concerns. Not only are many reformed and presbyterian churches allowing human innovations in worship, but the regulative principle of scripture and the correlative doctrine of the sufficiency of the bible. Reformed worship follows the release earlier this year of the same authors.
The normative principle of worship is the generally accepted approach to worship outside of reformed circles as practiced by anglicans, methodist, baptists, and independent bible churches. The regulative and normative principles of worship new. The clearest statement of this principle is found in wcf 21. Three principles for reformed and reforming worship the. You see there is no neutrality in the way in which we approach god in worship. Reformed worship follows the release earlier this year of the same author s. My first two posts in this series focused on the baconian and reformed character of alexander campbells hermeneutic. If it isnt in the bible, it cannot be in a worship setting. Such practices invalidate their claim, revealing it to be a hollow shell.
Put simply, the regulative principle of worship states that the corporate worship of god is to be founded upon specific directions of scripture. It is that public worship of god to which we seek to apply the regulative principle of worship. It states that worship of god can only be properly accomplished by what is commanded in scripture or by what can be deduced from scripture and without violation to it. Nov 05, 2007 awesome principles on how to worship the lord. I have encountered many things over the years, but thought that at least in name to remain confessional rpw was expected. Matthew mcmahon articles on puritan worship and the regulative principle today, many christians are turning back to the puritans to, walk in the old paths, of gods word, and to continue to proclaim old truth that glorifies jesus christ. On tuesday, may 24, 2016, hughes oliphant old died in his home in white river junction, vermont.
And the answer is already implied in our firm adherence to the bible as the inspired word of god the only infallible rule of faith and practice. Both hold to the truth of gods word, but they differ on whether or not it clearly establishes an unalterable blueprint for corporate worship. The regulative principle of worship is a christian doctrine, held by some calvinists and. In john 4, we have the two fundamental sides of the regulative principle of worship. In this volume johnson argues a cogent biblical case for worship according to the historic understanding of the regulative principle. Let it be clear from the outset that my questions about the reformed regulative principle for public worship do not spring from doubts about what i take to be its main thrust.
Other biblical principles 1 the sola scriptura principle. The regulative principle of worship is gods ordained law for worship. Hi john, the question isnt whether there are anglicans who still believe historic reformed doctrine e. Reformed worship is religious devotion to god as conducted by reformed or calvinistic christians, including presbyterians. Would that all churches who claim to bear the reformed mantle base their theology of worship around these principles. The use of instruments in public worship did not continue into the new covenant era. These sonnets are written to follow the order of worship and can be used by individuals for personal reflection, or in worship with households, small groups, or full congregations interspersed. The regulative principle of worship rpw is the doctrine that everything of religious significance in worship must be prescribed in holy scripture, either explicitly or by good and necessary consequence, such that. In this section of the site, the reader will find a number of works that hold a christian view, puritan view, a reformed view, of the regulative principle, and some other important matters throughout the history of the church, one of the most important topics found throughout the bible, or, for that matter, the lives of the most wellknown people of god, is the nature of true worship.
Reformation worship, the regulative principle, iconoclasm, etc. Even within a conservative reformed framework, worship leaders may disagree about musical style, transitions, volume, tempo, and many other factors. Biblical guidelines for emerging liturgies by sam hamstra, jr. Hart and muether do a great job of informing the reader in a way that is gentle yet convicting. The regulative principle is the understanding of how christians are to worship god as instructed in the bible. It is important to spell this out, because now it is becoming common for professedly reformed churches to maintain that they hold to the regulative principle of worship at the same time as singing hymns, using organs, keeping christmas and so on. While worship should be intelligible, it should not be confused with evangelistic outreach and therefore ought not to lose its alien nature and heavenly focus. For john calvin, it was the issue of worship that necessitated the reformation. Worship should be done in a way that pleases god on the basis of his revealed will in holy scripture. One could even argue that the other great principal doctrines of the reformation such as sola gratia, sola fide are logically dependent upon sola scriptura.
May 15, 2015 glen clary, pastor of providence opc in pflugerville, tx, explains the origins, use, and wisdom of the regulative principle of worship. This is not the party line presentation but rather a real investigation into the thoughts of the reformers and the westminster divines on their understanding of how the scriptures are to regulate worship. Jan 01, 2010 for john calvin, it was the issue of worship that necessitated the reformation. Sam hamstra, a pastor in the christian reformed church, has written a helpful introduction to many topics in worship and liturgy, both theoretical and practical. Despite considerable local and national variation, public worship in most reformed and presbyterian churches is governed by the regulative principle of worship. The puritans knew the bibles position on worship very well. This book is a must read for anyone interested in historical reformed worship. Reformation worship, the regulative principle of worship rpw, iconoclasm, etc. And there are baptist confessions that communicate a belief in the regulative principle. There is nothing more important in life than worship. I think both sides are starting off on the wrong foot. We have also seen that the puritan regulative principle of worship has been fraught with difficulties from the very beginning. Pictures of christ, the second commandment regulative principle of worship and idolatry many free reformed resources.
This book lays out the exegetical case for the regulative principles of worship and then sets forth the biblical evidence that instrumental music was only authorized for use by priests and levites for the ceremonial temple worship. Many reformed churches hold to the regulative principle of worship but not all reformed churches do. The first is reformed liturgy, and the second is posture in worship. Conflict over preferences will remain even with the regulative principle. How the origin of life points to the existence of god duration. The early church worshipped in a specific manner according to gods word. The regulative principle of worship reformed books online. Jan 02, 2020 both hold to the truth of gods word, but they differ on whether or not it clearly establishes an unalterable blueprint for corporate worship. The regulative principle over the next three weeks, i will cover five principles that govern christian worship. The immense body of reformation material books, mp3s and videos on the puritan hard drive, along with the phenomenal proprietary software program that is. The regulative principle of worship free presbyterian.
Reformed believers today need to understand the theological relationship that exists between sola scriptura and the regulative principle of worship. Which is correct, the regulative principle or the normative. We therefore include, at this point, a very brief statement of these principles as they bear on this issue. Sola scriptura and the regulative principle of worship brian schwertley introduction sola scriptura is one of the fundamental principles of the protestant reformation. The regulative principle of worship which is sola scriptura applied to the worship. Regulative principle of worship midcities presbyterian. We pray that this study will be used for the reformation of the church. Jun, 2003 the regulative principle, which is the historic way by which reformed people have addressed the worship issue, speaks both to truth and spirit. There is a growing need to study the doctrine of the church and the doctrine of worship. In this post i describe how churches of christ have embraced the reformed regulative principle and applied it with a reformed understanding of command, example and inference cei. On this section of the site, the reader will find a number of works that hold a christian view, puritan view, a reformed view, of the regulative principle, and some other important matters throughout the history of the church, one of the most important topics found throughout the bible, or, for that matter, the lives of the most wellknown people of god, is the nature of true worship.
A common theme among reformed writers is that worship encompasses all of life. Christ and his commands are the rule by which christians gather together for worship. Normative worship looks at the other side of the coin. While the more liturgical churches, such as catholic. Regulative worship relies upon scripture to dictate specifically what is allowed in worship.
The regulative principle of worship by derek thomas. The regulative principle of worship banner of truth usa. Rather than scripture providing the directive for how we are to conduct public worship, the church is seen as the final authority in such matters. Ignorance on this subject is not bliss since god commands the gathering together of his people for the express purpose of worship heb. Generally speaking, the regulative principle is held by those who are reformed. The growing influence of the anglican tradition in.
In this brief post, i want to simply draw your attention to the use of the term worship in this discussion. Even those who want to modifyor entirely eliminatethe rpw are willing to concede as. John calvin on the regulative principle of worship by brian schwertley 4 free mp3s. Christians worship god because god created men male and female to worship him. Regulative principle of worship association of reformed. The regulative principle of worship in the old testament the second commandment in covenanter, puritan and reformation worship by greg price free mp3 and video the regulative principle of worship in the new testament the second commandment in covenanter, puritan and reformation worship by greg price free mp3 and video. For instance, the famous baptist pastor and theologian, john gill, held to the regulative principle. The clearest examination on the puritan regulative principle of worship i have read to date. The regulative principle is most often associated with reformed churches, while the normative principle is widely promoted by modern evangelicalism. In other words, it is the belief that god institutes in scripture whatever he requires for worship in the church, and everything else should be avoided. A brief theology and philosophy of worship university. And they have built the high places of tophet, which is in the valley of the son of hinno. Presbyterian churches have traditionally been guided by what has come to be called the regulative principle, based on the westminster confession of faith. If jesus did not follow the regulative principle of worship, claims gore, then neither should we.
Jan 11, 2017 that we in no wise make any image of god, nor worship him in any other way than he has commanded us in his word. Puritan worship and the regulative principle of worship. As one who came to the anglican tradition about eight years ago, and more recently to the reformed tradition, i have found the issue of the regulative principle of worship to be a hotly argued and more often than not, misunderstood teaching. Jesus answers the samaritan woman in verse 21, woman, believe me, an hour is coming when neither in this mountain. The growing influence of the anglican tradition in reformed worship. From the opening prayer to the closing scripture reading, confessional reformed worship services are ordered according to clear biblical principles. The regulative principle of worship reformed forum. The only question is whether we will worship the right one in the right way. The scriptural regulative principle of worship the.
O come let us worship series on reformed public worship rev. The doctrine further determines these affirmed elements to be those set forth in. The regulative principle of worship in christian theology teaches that the public worship of god should include those and only those elements that are instituted, commanded, or appointed by command or example in the bible. Articles on puritan worship and the regulative principle. Gores thesis may provoke some rethinking of principles of worship in years to come.
The regulative principle was given its classical and definitive statement in the reformed. Free reformation and puritan books, mp3s, debates and articles on puritan and reformation worship scroll down for free resources. The growing influence of the anglican tradition in reformed. Reformation worship, the regulative principle, iconoclasm. The regulative principle, which is the historic way by which reformed people have addressed the worship issue, speaks both to truth and spirit. Terry johnson concurs, and in this book he applies biblical principles to reform contemporary worship. The regulative principle of worship 68 ordained servantvol. Recognizing that truth, however, we also note the unique place of the public worship of god when the church gathers together on the lords day. Regulative and normative principles paul washer youtube.
Worship is the center of our existence, at the heart of our reason for beingold. The regulative principles does not completely eliminate the role of opinion and preference. Some questions about the regulative principlejohn m. Worship and the regulative principle reformed hope. The regulative principle of worship is a christian doctrine, held by some calvinists and anabaptists, that god commands churches to conduct public services of worship using certain distinct elements affirmatively found in scripture, and conversely, that god prohibits any and all other practices in public worship. This is called the regulative principle of worship and you can find it explained in various places in the reformed confessions hc qa 96, wlc qa 1089, etc. The chief reason is the current declension among the conservative reformed and presbyterian denominations today, particularly in the area of worship. In 1996 reformed theologian john frame broke the consensus and argued that the regulative principle. The regulative principle of worship is the doctrine of sola scriptura by scripture alone as necessarily applied to, and encompassing, the churchs worship. The regulative principle of worship holds that we worship god in the manner he has commanded us in his word. There is a lot that can be said about the debate between the regulative principle of worship versus the normative principle of worship. The regulative principle of worship defined we can only approach god on his own terms, not only for salvation, but also in worship.
Regulative principle booksarticles the puritan board. At urc we want all of life to be worship to god rom. See these reformed liturgies here calvin, knox and puritan comparisons see calvins strassborg liturgy here. The opposite of the regulative principle is the inventive principle, which has roman catholicism as its chief proponent.
1588 823 1343 544 346 1058 1113 1402 386 448 1403 883 545 1470 847 1340 69 1623 300 227 796 1121 733 372 802 182 285 109 1112 1428 739 1663 52 140 1057 1463 436 279 1091 1362 180 1230 900 1372 812